
From Bali to Rome, the urge for private justice tests legal systems
Indonesian police investigate a mob slaying, a Malaysian father is assaulted outside a school, Italy weighs a self-defence law, and US families fight to keep killers imprisoned.
Indonesian police are reviewing surveillance footage and have questioned witnesses in the mob killing of a man suspected of stealing a chicken in Tabanan, Bali, on 24 July. The victim, identified by his initials KD, was beaten to death by residents after allegedly being caught attempting to take a fighting cock. His motorcycle was set alight at the scene. The family of the deceased, who described the incident as a 'calamity', has apologised to the community, while a viral video of the man’s young daughter weeping beside his coffin prompted widespread expressions of grief on social media. The Bali provincial police have urged citizens not to resort to extrajudicial action and are investigating both the alleged theft and the fatal assault.
Separately, in Selangor, Malaysia, a 16-year-old student was assaulted by a group from his school outside the premises on 3 July. When his father arrived to intervene, the parent was struck and fell onto the road, an attack captured on video that circulated three weeks later. Police in Serdang have detained several individuals and are investigating under the rioting provision of the penal code. The incident comes amid persistently high levels of school bullying and misconduct. Ministry of Education data recorded 7,681 cases of bullying in 2024, a rise attributed by officials to improved reporting after a 2023 directive, and an additional 3,570 disciplinary infractions categorised as criminal offences in 2025, the majority in secondary schools. In Alor Gajah, a father who allegedly threatened three students with a knife, claiming his child had been bullied, further highlights the tensions around school security.
In Italy, the cabinet has approved a decree that, according to opposition figures and legal commentators in Rome, would legitimise self-justice while simultaneously lowering the threshold for full criminal responsibility in minors. The measure would exempt an adult who kills in retribution—even hours after an attack—from punishment under an expanded self-defence doctrine, yet would treat a 14-year-old as fully accountable and could allow 16-year-olds to be incarcerated with adults. Magistrates and child-rights groups contend the move contradicts core principles of the juvenile justice system, which traditionally emphasises rehabilitation over pure punitiveness. They warn that the combination of relaxed self-defence rules and harsher treatment of minors could deepen societal tendencies towards vengeance, at a time when prison resources for educational programmes are being cut.
Viewed from California, the impulse to ensure severe consequences for violent offenders has long been channelled through victims’ rights legislation. The families of Catina Salarno, killed in 1979 by her boyfriend, and Justine Vanderschoot, murdered by two teenage peers in 2003, have spent decades opposing parole for the convicted killers. Their campaigns helped shape measures such as California’s Victims’ Bill of Rights and the state’s lifetime parole-emergency revocation process. Currently, the Vanderschoots are contesting the seventh attempt by Danny Bezemer and Brandon Fernandez to win release. Relatives describe the ongoing parole hearings as a persistent trauma that reopens wounds, yet they continue to advocate for a system that they see as the only legitimate form of accountability.
The Indonesian police investigation is ongoing, with officers analysing CCTV and collecting evidence to identify all suspects; charges of causing death during a riot are possible. In Malaysia, the school assault case is advancing under Section 147 of the Penal Code. The Italian decree now moves to parliamentary debate, where it is expected to face stiff resistance from opposition parties and child-rights groups. In the United States, the next parole hearing for the Vanderschoot killers is scheduled, keeping alive a four-decade pattern of legal and personal endurance.
Broaden your view
Iran vows retaliation as Ukraine strikes vessel in Caspian Sea
4 languages · 10 outlets
From Economy & MarketsCXMT Debut Values Chinese Chipmaker at $490bn, Topping Mainland Market
6 languages · 12 outlets
From TechnologyChina Launches Multi‑Pronged AI Cooperation with Developing Countries
3 languages · 4 outlets